Remworth

Account healthProduct reviews: what sellers
may and may not do.

Amazon's product review rules for sellers come down to one line in its code of conduct: you may ask your own customers for reviews in a neutral way, but you may not try to influence them. Amazon calls its stance zero tolerance, and the FTC's own rule on fake reviews and testimonials has been in effect since October 21, 2024. Here is what each rule says, where the Request a Review button fits, and where to check your account.

Account health · Published October 5, 2026 · Checked against the sources below on October 4, 2026 · 7 min read

Amazon's review rule in one line

Amazon's seller code of conduct says sellers must not attempt to influence customers' ratings, feedback and reviews. The same page says you may request feedback and reviews from your own customers "in a neutral manner".

What the code of conduct bans

  • Paying for, or offering an incentive such as coupons or free products, in exchange for a review or feedback, or for removing one.
  • Asking customers to write only positive reviews, or asking them to remove or change a review.
  • Asking for reviews only from customers who had a positive experience.
  • Reviewing your own products or a competitor's products.

What Amazon offers instead

  • Request a Review, a button on the order's Order details page in Seller Central (more below).
  • Report abuse. If a review doesn't follow Amazon's Community Guidelines, report it from the product detail page. You can't change reviews, but Amazon says it removes reviews that violate its policies.
  • Amazon Vine. Amazon says enrolling products in the Vine program helps generate high-quality reviews. Check in Seller Central whether your products can be enrolled.

What Amazon counts as review manipulation

Amazon's Customer product reviews policies page lists these violations, and says the list is not complete:

  • Reviewing your own product or a competitor's, including from a customer account.
  • Reviews of your products, or a competitor's, by your family members or employees.
  • Offering a financial reward, discount, free products or other compensation for a review, including through services that sell reviews, websites, social media groups, or review clubs that tie free or discounted products to a review.
  • Asking a reviewer to change or remove a review, including by offering a refund or reimbursement, even through a non-Amazon payment method.
  • Sending negative reviews to you or to another feedback channel while positive ones go to Amazon.
  • Putting a request for a positive Amazon review, or an incentive for a review, in the product packaging or shipping box.
  • Creating a variation relationship (related products, such as sizes or colors, offered from one product detail page) to pool reviews and boost the star rating.

People who work for you count as you

The policy says "seller" includes your employees and third-party partners, and their infractions lead to enforcement against you "even if it happened without your knowledge or consent." Amazon asks you to teach the rules to your business partners, employees and any third-party partners you work with.

What Amazon says it does

Amazon calls it a "zero-tolerance policy". The actions it lists include:

  • Immediate and permanent withdrawal of selling privileges, and withholding of funds.
  • Removing all of the product's reviews and blocking future reviews or ratings.
  • Permanently delisting the product from Amazon.
  • Legal action, including lawsuits and referral to civil and criminal enforcement authorities.
  • Publicly disclosing the seller's name and other related information.

How the Request a Review button works

Open the order in Seller Central and click Request a Review on its Order details page. Amazon then sends the buyer an automated review request. Amazon's developer documentation describes the request sent through its API as asking the buyer for both seller feedback and a product review.

  • Once per order. Amazon's developer documentation says to send only one such request per order. If an app has already sent one through the API, clicking the button returns an error that a review was already requested.
  • Delivered orders, in Amazon's window. Amazon's developer guide says to ask about orders that have been delivered and to prompt for feedback "within the allowed time frame". An app checks with Amazon whether each order is eligible before it sends a request.
  • No replies. Buyers can't respond to requests sent through Amazon's Solicitations API, and those requests don't appear in the Messaging section of Seller Central.
  • Apps can send it too, through the Solicitations API, under the same one-per-order limit. A request sent that way doesn't flag the order in Seller Central.

Amazon's rules cover who you ask as well as what you say. Its code of conduct bans soliciting reviews "only from customers who had a positive experience", and its developer guide says you cannot "selectively seek positive reviews". Amazon's seller guidance also says not to ask customers to post positive reviews, so a message of your own asking for a good review breaks the rule.

The FTC's rule on fake reviews and testimonials

Amazon's policy isn't the only rule. On August 14, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission announced a final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials, approved by a 5-0 vote. The Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials went into effect on October 21, 2024, and it lets courts impose civil penalties for knowing violations. In plain words, it bans:

  • Fake or false reviews and testimonials: ones that claim to come from someone who doesn't exist (AI-generated fakes included) or who had no real experience with the product. A business may not create or sell them, or buy them when it knew or should have known they were fake or false.
  • Buying positive or negative reviews: any compensation or incentive conditioned on the review expressing a particular sentiment, whether that condition is stated or implied.
  • Undisclosed insider reviews: certain reviews and testimonials by company insiders, such as officers and managers, without a clear and conspicuous disclosure of their connection to the business.
  • Company-controlled review websites that claim to give independent reviews of a category that includes the company's own products.
  • Review suppression: unfounded or groundless legal threats, physical threats, intimidation or certain false public accusations used to prevent or remove a negative review.
  • Fake social media influence: selling or buying fake followers or views, such as ones generated by a bot or a hijacked account, when the buyer knew or should have known they were fake and uses them to misrepresent its influence for a commercial purpose.

Where Amazon's policy goes further than the FTC rule

The FTC rule and Amazon's policy, as each page states them (read October 4, 2026)
PracticeFTC ruleAmazon policy
An incentive for a review, whatever the review saysNot banned by the rule unless the review must express a particular sentiment. The FTC adds that failing to disclose incentives could violate the FTC Act.Banned: no payment or incentive, such as coupons or free products, in exchange for a review.
Asking only customers you think are happyThe FTC's Q&A says the rule "does not contain a specific prohibition" against it, but adds that the practice could violate the FTC Act.Banned.
A reward that depends on a positive (or negative) reviewBanned.Banned.
Reviews by your staff or familyCertain insider reviews are banned unless the connection is clearly and conspicuously disclosed.Listed as a violation.
Getting a negative review changed or taken downThreats, intimidation and certain false public accusations are banned. The rule doesn't ban paying someone to change or remove a review, but the FTC says paying to change or remove truthful negative reviews may violate the FTC Act.Asking a reviewer to change or remove a review is a violation, with or without an offer.

Product reviews vs seller feedback

Amazon keeps two separate ratings. A product review describes the product: its quality, function or usefulness. Seller feedback covers the experience the seller gave the buyer: reliability, quality and the overall fulfillment experience. The code of conduct covers both.

  • Buyers leave seller feedback from their Orders page: one per order, within 90 days of the order date.
  • On seller-fulfilled orders, negative feedback (1 and 2 stars) counts toward your Order Defect Rate (ODR), along with A-to-z Guarantee claims and credit card chargebacks, over a 60-day period. Amazon requires an ODR under 1%.
  • For negative feedback, Amazon points you to Feedback Manager: contact the customer to work out what went wrong, or request removal if you believe the feedback is incorrect and it meets Amazon's requirements for removal.

Where to check your account in Seller Central

Customer Product Reviews Policies, Communication guidelines and the seller code of conduct are all on Amazon's list of policies included in the Account Health Rating (AHR). Amazon shows the AHR on your Account Health page in Seller Central.

The AHR runs from 0 to 1,000 for each store you sell in: 200 to 1,000 is green ("Healthy"), 100 to 199 is yellow ("At Risk"), and 99 or lower is red ("Unhealthy"), meaning eligible for deactivation or already deactivated. Violations cost points by severity, and repeats of the same policy cost more each time. Reaching the limit on repeat violations of one policy in a 180-day period can put an account at immediate risk of deactivation, and that limit "can be as low as two" for higher-severity violations. Whatever the score, Amazon says it may deactivate an account immediately if it suspects fraudulent, deceptive, illegal or otherwise harmful activity.

A short routine

  1. Read the reviews policy and the code of conduct in Seller Central Help, and share them with anyone who works for you.
  2. Use Request a Review, or an app that uses Amazon's API, and don't pick who gets a request by whether you expect a good review.
  3. Keep requests for positive reviews, and any incentive for a review, out of your packaging and shipping boxes.
  4. Check Account Health and address listed violations promptly, the most severe first.
  5. Keep your Emergency Contact phone number current: Amazon says it may call to offer support if your account health degrades and becomes eligible for deactivation.

Remworth's Account Health page shows how Amazon rates your account, what buyers have said about you, and the review requests you send, and links you to Seller Central to act on it. Automatic review requests are a setting, off by default: each day Remworth asks Amazon to send its official review-request email for eligible recent orders, one request per order. New to Seller Central? Start with our Amazon seller account guide.

Questions

Review rule questions

Can I give a free product or a discount for an honest review on Amazon?

No. Amazon's code of conduct bans paying for or offering an incentive, such as coupons or free products, in exchange for a review, whatever the review says. The FTC's rule bans only incentives tied to a particular sentiment (and the FTC says failing to disclose an incentive could violate the FTC Act), but Amazon's policy is stricter, and it is the one Amazon enforces on your account. Amazon's own option is Amazon Vine; check in Seller Central whether your products can be enrolled.

Can I ask a customer to remove or change a negative review?

No. Amazon's code of conduct bans asking customers to remove or change a review, and its reviews policy lists offering a refund or other compensation for doing so as a violation. If a review doesn't follow Amazon's Community Guidelines, report it from the product detail page. Amazon says it removes reviews that violate its policies.

How many times can I use Request a Review on one order?

Once. Amazon's developer documentation says to send only one review-and-feedback request per order, and if an app already sent one, the Seller Central button returns an error that a review was already requested. Amazon's guidance is to ask about delivered orders, within the allowed time frame.

Can I put a card in the box asking for a review?

Not one that asks for a positive review or offers anything for a review. Amazon's reviews policy lists putting either in the product packaging or shipping box as a violation, and its code of conduct bans any incentive for a review.

Can my family or employees review my products?

Not on Amazon. Amazon's reviews policy lists a review by a seller's family member or employee, of the seller's product or a competitor's, as a violation, and it counts your employees and third-party partners as you. The FTC rule is narrower: it bans certain insider reviews that don't clearly and conspicuously disclose the connection.

Do product reviews count toward my Order Defect Rate?

No. Amazon's ODR page lists negative seller feedback (1 and 2 stars), A-to-z Guarantee claims and credit card chargebacks, on seller-fulfilled orders only. A product review rates the product, not your order. Breaking the review policies does count against your Account Health Rating, which includes Customer Product Reviews Policies.

Keep an eye on account health, not just sales.

Remworth's Account Health page shows how Amazon rates your account and the review requests you send, and automatic requests stay off until you turn them on. Start the 7-day trial (card required) and connect your amazon.com seller account.

Solo $199.99/mo · Pro $349.99/mo · 7 days free, card required

On your phone? Start with just your email. The link we email you works once, on any device, within 7 days, and the app opens once you've picked a plan, added your card and connected your Amazon seller account.

Your Amazon password stays with Amazon. How Remworth connects.

Sources

  1. Amazon Seller Central Help: Selling policies and seller code of conduct no influencing ratings, feedback or reviews; neutral requests to your own customers allowed; the four review bans; messages only through Buyer-Seller Messaging, needed for the order or customer service, no marketing; read October 4, 2026 (seller login)
  2. Amazon Seller Central Help: Customer product reviews policies the listed violations; "seller" includes employees and third-party partners; enforcement even without your knowledge; zero tolerance and the actions Amazon lists
  3. Amazon Seller Central Help: ASIN creation policy what a variation relationship is: related products, such as size or color, offered from one product detail page
  4. Amazon Seller Central Help: Policies included in Account Health Rating Customer Product Reviews Policies, Communication guidelines and the code of conduct are included in the AHR
  5. Amazon Seller Central Help: Account Health Rating program policy the 0 to 1,000 score per store and its three bands, severity points, repeat violations within 180 days, immediate deactivation, addressing violations by severity, the Emergency Contact number
  6. Amazon Seller Central Help: Monitor feedback and performance product review vs seller feedback; feedback left from the Orders page, one per order, within 90 days of the order date
  7. Amazon Seller Central Help: Order Defect Rate ODR under 1% over 60 days on seller-fulfilled orders; 1- and 2-star feedback is negative; Feedback Manager contact and removal requests
  8. Sell on Amazon: Customer Reviews tool Request a Review on the Order details page sends automated review requests; Amazon Vine; report abuse from the product detail page; sellers can't change reviews; Amazon removes reviews that violate its policies; don't ask customers to post positive reviews
  9. Amazon Selling Partner API docs: Solicit feedback for an order eligibility checked with Amazon before sending; no flag in Seller Central; the "already requested" error; delivered orders, within the allowed time frame; no selective, altered or incentivized requests
  10. Amazon Selling Partner API docs: createProductReviewAndSellerFeedbackSolicitation the request asks the buyer for seller feedback and a product review; send only one per order
  11. Amazon Selling Partner API docs: Solicitations v1 buyers cannot respond to these requests, and they don't appear in the Messaging section of Seller Central
  12. FTC press release: Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (August 14, 2024) the six prohibitions, the 5-0 vote, civil penalties against knowing violators
  13. FTC: The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers in effect October 21, 2024; civil penalties for knowing violations; incentives not conditioned on sentiment, and disclosure under the FTC Act; no specific ban on asking only happy customers, but it could violate the FTC Act; family reviews with disclosure; paying to change or remove truthful negative reviews; your website or third-party review platforms