Remworth

ProfitFIFO vs average cost:
same units, different monthly profit.

FIFO and average cost are two ways to decide what a sale cost you when you bought the same product at different prices. Once everything is sold, they add up to the same total. Month to month, and at year-end, they can come out different whenever your buy price changed. Here is each method, what the IRS says, a worked example, and the mistakes to avoid.

Profit · Published October 5, 2026 · Checked against the sources below on October 4, 2026 · 7 min read

FIFO and average cost in plain English

Your buy price for the same product can change from one purchase to the next. A supplier raises its price, a store marks a product down, an online deal ends. When one of those units sells on Amazon, your books need a rule for which price goes with the sale.

  • FIFO (first in, first out) assumes the units you bought first are the first ones you sold. IRS Publication 538 adds that the items left at the end of the tax year are matched with the costs of similar items you bought most recently.
  • Average cost spreads what you paid across all your units: total cost divided by the number of units. A rolling average is recomputed as you go, for example each time you buy more.
  • Specific identification matches each item to its actual cost. Publication 538 says to use FIFO or LIFO instead when you can't, or when goods of the same type are "intermingled" in your inventory and can't be identified with specific invoices (for example, identical units from two orders stored together).

Worked example: your supplier raises the price

This is an example with round numbers, not a real account. One product, and each sale leaves $15.00 after Amazon's fees (an example figure).

  • August: you buy 100 units at $6.00. Cost: $600.
  • September: the supplier raises its price. You buy 100 more at $9.00. Cost: $900.
  • October: you sell 120 units. November: you sell the other 80.

The average cost after both orders is $1,500 ÷ 200 units = $7.50 a unit. Both orders arrive before the first October sale, so a rolling average also gives $7.50 here.

Example: the same 200 units under FIFO and average cost
LineFIFOAverage cost
October cost of goods sold (120 units)100 × $6 + 20 × $9 = $780120 × $7.50 = $900
October profit ($1,800 left after fees)$1,020$900
Value of the 80 units left on October 3180 × $9 = $72080 × $7.50 = $600
November cost of goods sold (80 units)$720$600
November profit ($1,200 left after fees)$480$600
Two-month profit$1,500$1,500

Example figures. You spent $1,500 either way. Only the month each dollar of cost lands in changes.

Three things to notice:

  • October looks $120 better under FIFO, because the cheap August units sell first.
  • November looks $120 worse under FIFO. The first 100 sales make $9.00 each, and every sale after that makes $6.00, the same margin a new order at $9 would earn at this sale price. Under the average, every sale makes $7.50 until a new order shifts it.
  • If October 31 were your year-end, the units on hand would be worth $720 under FIFO and $600 under average cost. That ending inventory figure decides how much cost lands in this tax year and how much in the next.

When prices fall, the pattern flips: FIFO puts the older, higher cost into the earlier sales. Publication 538 describes the same swing between FIFO and LIFO: with rising prices, FIFO gives a lower cost of goods sold and a higher closing inventory than LIFO, and when prices fall, "the opposite will hold."

Why the method matters to a reseller

  • Arbitrage prices can move from trip to trip. A clearance shelf, a coupon, a different store: the same product can cost you something different every time you buy it. The method decides which of those prices each sale carries.
  • Wholesale prices can change between orders. A supplier increase reaches your profit at different times under each method, as in the example.
  • Profit can drive your reorders. If you decide whether to buy again from last month's profit per unit, check whether that figure reflects the batch you just sold (FIFO) or a blend of everything you've bought (average).
  • Year-end inventory goes on your tax return. On Schedule C, the form for a sole proprietorship, ending inventory has its own line (41), cost of goods sold is figured from it (42), and line 35, beginning inventory, needs an explanation attached if it differs from last year's closing inventory.

What the IRS says about inventory methods

IRS Publication 538 names three ways to identify the cost of items in inventory: specific identification, FIFO and LIFO. Average cost is not on that list. LIFO (last in, first out) assumes the items you bought last are the first ones sold; to adopt it, you file Form 970, or a statement with the same information, with your timely filed return for the first year you use it.

Averages come up separately. In Revenue Procedure 2008-43, the IRS said it had "traditionally viewed" rolling-average valuation as not clearly reflecting income, especially when inventory is held for several years or costs fluctuate substantially. The same document says the IRS will generally view a rolling average that a business uses in its financial accounting as clearly reflecting income for tax purposes, though with long-held inventory or big cost swings it "may or may not." It then set two safe harbors under which that rolling average counts as clearly reflecting income: recompute the average with each purchase or at least once a month, and either keep the variance against a FIFO or specific-identification ending inventory at 1% or less, or turn the whole inventory at least four times a year.

Rules that apply whatever method you use

  • Be consistent. The method must clearly reflect income, and "your inventory practices must be consistent from year to year" (Publication 538).
  • Changing methods takes a form. To change your method of accounting for inventory, you file Form 3115.
  • What counts as cost. For merchandise bought during the year, cost is the invoice price minus appropriate discounts, plus transportation or other charges incurred in acquiring the goods. Trade or quantity discounts must come off. Which of your shipping costs count is a question for your accountant.
  • Small business taxpayers can choose not to keep an inventory, but must still use a method of accounting for inventory that clearly reflects income. Publication 538 explains who qualifies.
  • Keep the paper. IRS Publication 583 lists canceled checks, cash register tape receipts, credit card sales slips and invoices as documents that report the cost of inventory, and says these records help you determine its value at the end of the year.

Where your cost shows up in Seller Central

Two Seller Central features use a cost you enter, each for one job: one sets what Amazon reimburses, the other estimates the value of a restock order.

  • Manage Your Sourcing Cost, on the Inventory Defect & Reimbursement portal. When Amazon reimburses an FBA unit lost or damaged before a customer ordered it (shipment to Amazon, removal and fulfillment center claims), it pays your sourcing cost, or a reduced estimated cost if the unit was in unsellable condition. If you don't provide a sourcing cost, Amazon uses its own estimate, shown on the same page. Amazon's sourcing cost excludes costs "such as shipping, handling, customs duties," so it can differ from the IRS cost above, which adds transportation.
  • Restock Inventory. The "cost of purchase" replenishment setting is the per-unit cost you pay to order the product from your supplier. Amazon multiplies it by the recommended replenishment quantity to get the estimated shipment value amount: the value of the inventory you're restocking.

If you enter a sourcing cost, Amazon says it may ask for more information to validate the amount. The Manage Your Sourcing Cost page has the details of the proof-of-value documents it accepts.

Common mistakes

  • Overwriting the cost with the newest price. One cost per product, updated with each order, is neither FIFO nor an average. If profit is recalculated from that one cell, every past sale gets repriced at today's cost.
  • Booking a sale at $0 because no cost was entered. That sale's profit is overstated by the whole cost of the unit.
  • Mixing methods. An average in your spreadsheet and FIFO in your books will disagree in any month your buy price moved, as in the example.
  • Carrying damaged units at full cost. Publication 538 says goods you can't sell at normal prices because of damage, imperfections or similar causes should be valued at their bona fide selling price minus the direct cost of disposition, whatever method you use for the rest.
  • Losing the receipts. FIFO needs the date, quantity and price of every purchase. For retail arbitrage, that record is often a store receipt.

Where Remworth fits

Remworth keeps FIFO for your Amazon business: each purchase you receive becomes its own cost layer at the price you paid, and each sale draws from the oldest layer first. There is no average-cost setting, and sales with no recorded cost are held out of profit rather than booked at a fake $0. It isn't tax software and doesn't pick your tax inventory method; that stays with you and your accountant. See how FIFO costing works in Remworth.

Questions

Questions sellers ask

Can I use average cost for my Amazon inventory on my taxes?

IRS Publication 538 names specific identification, FIFO and LIFO as the ways to identify inventory cost. The IRS covers rolling averages separately in Revenue Procedure 2008-43, for a business that already uses one in its financial accounting, with two safe harbors. Ask your accountant whether any of it fits your return. This is not tax advice.

Does FIFO mean Amazon ships my oldest units first?

No. FIFO is a rule in your books about which cost goes with a sale; Publication 538 says the method "assumes" the items bought first are the first sold. It doesn't depend on which physical unit Amazon shipped.

Do FIFO and average cost give different total profit?

Not once everything is sold: in the example above, both show $1,500 over two months. They can differ in which month, and which tax year, the profit lands in, through the value of the units you still hold.

Start your cost layers with the next order.

Connect your Amazon account and receive your next supplier order in Remworth. The cost layers start that day. FIFO costing comes with both plans.

Solo $199.99/mo · Pro $349.99/mo · 7 days free, card required

On your phone? Start with just your email. The link we email you works once, on any device, within 7 days, and the app opens once you've picked a plan, added your card and connected your Amazon seller account.

Your Amazon password stays with Amazon. How Remworth connects.

Sources

  1. IRS Publication 538, Accounting Periods and Methods (Rev. January 2022) the three cost identification methods (specific identification, FIFO, LIFO); the FIFO and LIFO definitions; intermingled goods; FIFO vs LIFO with rising and falling prices; consistency from year to year; Form 970 and Form 3115; cost of purchased merchandise and trade discounts; the small business taxpayer exception; goods that cannot be sold
  2. IRS Revenue Procedure 2008-43 the IRS's traditional view of rolling-average valuation; its general view of a rolling average used in financial accounting; the two safe harbors (recompute per purchase or at least monthly; a variance of 1% or less against FIFO or specific identification, or four inventory turns a year)
  3. IRS Schedule C (Form 1040), 2025 Profit or Loss From Business (Sole Proprietorship); Part III lines 35, 41 and 42
  4. IRS Publication 583, Starting a Business and Keeping Records (Rev. December 2024) documents that report the cost of inventory: canceled checks, cash register tape receipts, credit card sales slips, invoices; they help determine year-end inventory value
  5. Seller Central Help: FBA inventory reimbursement policy sourcing cost paid for units lost or damaged before a customer order, a reduced estimated cost for unsellable units; Amazon's own estimate if you don't provide one; sourcing cost excludes shipping, handling and customs duties; Amazon may ask for validation; read October 4, 2026
  6. Seller Central Help: Restock Inventory the cost of purchase replenishment setting and the estimated shipment value amount; read October 4, 2026